this is how I'm supposed to be
 Blogs I Like
 Links Page
 Contact
  • asfo_del [ at ] yahoo.com
Green Day on a Par with Joe Strummer and Johnny Cash
Posted by Delfina

There’s a new interview with Antonino D’Ambrosio, the author of the books Let Fury Have the Hour, about Joe Strummer of The Clash (which I read a few years ago), and A Heartbeat and a Guitar, about Johnny Cash, two artists known for their passionate commitment to political issues in their music.

When asked if there are artists today who are carrying on the tradition of Joe Strummer and Johnny Cash, he says:

“There are scores of artists that say something, but they’re just not at level where they’re affecting the wider culture the way that Johnny Cash or Joe Strummer did. Green Day is at that level, and American Idiot is a powerful statement. I would say certainly Green Day is there, but they’re an exception.”

Wow. Seeing Green Day compared to Strummer and Cash almost gave me goose bumps. And seeing them get credit as being in a class of their own, by someone whose own interests are deeply grounded in the power of art and music to affect social consciousness, is gratifying as well.

D’Ambrosio sees all artistic output as political in some way, because whether an artist directly addresses broader issues or skirts around them, he or she cannot avoid making some kind of statement. Avoiding political issues is not necessarily non-political, in his view, because built into the silence is a tacit acceptance and support of the status quo.

I tend to agree. I think telling the truth is political in itself, because it’s liberating to both artist and audience. Even Green Day’s early songs about girls and loneliness are liberating, because they’re so painfully honest. The way that Green Day has gone about making music has always been very down-to-earth, and the stories they tell are about the things people care about and that affect their lives, whether privately or publicly. (A lot of other music that’s out there, on the other hand, that’s about making money, gaining fame, or looking at women as objects, is political too, but in a negative sense, not because it’s liberating but because it’s oppressive.)

I’m not sure if the public is terribly receptive to the political and liberatory potential of popular music these days, but D’Ambrosio is hopeful, and I want to close with his encouraging words:

I’m always ultimately hopeful and optimistic because there are always going to be artists out there who respond to the moment. They’re going to produce work that becomes the next chapter in the progressive movement of humanity. I think ultimately, in a way, music is that. The very idea of making music is a rebellious act.

November 21, 2009 at 4:21 pm [ Category: Political ]

Comment from oldrocker November 22, 2009, 12:28 am

Love this one, Delfina. In particular, AI was my real intro to Green Day, and came at a time that I was(politically) despairing. It made a huge difference to me, giving expression to my pain and rage, and also hope. On top of that, the music and lyrics were gorgeous. Only the Dixie Chicks had so plainly spoken out up till then. I also grew up when politics was typically dealt with in song by the likes of Bob Dylan, Joan Baez, The Beatles, et al, so I really missed that aspect. Since then, I now have all their albums, and see that they were really political from the start. People don’t seem to understand that their songs about relationships were very political, and, as you say, painfully honest. Thanks for a great commentary, as usual.

Comment from Elly November 23, 2009, 11:39 am

I never had a problem comparing Green Day to the Clash, or Billie Joe toJoe Strummer for that matter. Both bands mean the world to me and I figured they were so similar as it were! I loved the political audacity of the Clash and Joe Strummer- and surely without them Green Day may not have happened. It’s good to see that the band is finally getting some recognition for just how great they really are. If you ask me, Mr. Strummer would be proud. :D

Comment from Abbey November 23, 2009, 12:15 pm

ive always felt hard-wired on politics without any inkling of being a political person…meaning there are just some things that i believe that come from the mysterious core. its when songwriters reach the honesty of that core that it really speaks to me and its ALL political in a sense…its what we believe in…it’s who we are

Write a comment